HMRC Landlord Reporting: Are Landlords About to Be Treated Like They’re on Bail?
Landlords have been hit repeatedly in recent years, and the latest HMRC consultation papers suggest more is coming. The proposals would require letting agents or other representatives to report details of landlords’ rental businesses to HMRC regularly, including personal information such as National Insurance numbers and dates of birth. This article explains what is being proposed, what landlords have already faced, and why it matters if you hold property in your own name, in a company, in a trust or in a partnership.
Landlord Tax Hits Since the Budget
Consider what landlords are already dealing with:
-
- The Renters’ Rights changes and the new landlord database.
-
- Additional levies and costs if you add value to a property.
-
- The mortgage interest restriction (Section 24).
-
- Higher income tax rates on property income from April 2027.
It might be reasonable to expect landlords to be left alone after all of that. Instead, HMRC is moving ahead with something new.
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax Thresholds
Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax affects people with unincorporated income, including sole traders, partnerships and landlords. The threshold is based on combined gross income from these activities, so rental income and self-employed income are added together. The threshold is coming down in stages:
| Date | Combined Gross Income Threshold |
|---|---|
| Currently | Over £50,000 |
| From April 2027 | Over £30,000 |
| From April 2028 | Over £20,000 |
A £20,000 threshold will capture most landlords. The wider problem is that people are being taxed so heavily that they may not be making much profit, while the compliance burden of reporting continues to climb.
HMRC Wants Landlord Data From Letting Agents
On top of MTD, HMRC wants more information. Going forward, the proposal is that your letting agent or representative reports everything about your rental business to HMRC regularly. That includes your National Insurance number and date of birth, as well as details of the tenant. The expectation is that a third party provides this rather than the landlord, and the letting agent is the starting point. It would be no surprise to see accountants brought into the same system later.
HMRC Consultation Closes 20 January
This is currently a consultation, and it is understood to close on 20 January. If you want to give feedback to HMRC and the government, now is the time. Links to the consultation and to the discussion document will be added so you can read what is being proposed for yourself.
Is the HMRC Tax Gap Real?
The reason given for these measures is the need to close the tax gap, which seems to get bigger every time it is mentioned. It is worth asking what the gap is being compared to, and what the estimate is based on. The gap is the difference between what HMRC thinks should be collected and what it actually receives, and a large share of it is said to relate to big corporates, which are too clever and powerful to chase. The result is that individual business owners and landlords end up bearing the weight of enforcement.
In the video, Zee also questions the credibility of the figures, pointing out that HMRC “haven’t passed audit for probably a couple of decades”.
Monthly Reporting Plans for Landlords
Perhaps the most striking detail is how often the information would be reported: HMRC is considering monthly reporting, not even quarterly. Each submission would include the landlord’s date of birth, National Insurance number, and the tenant’s details. HMRC does not trust landlords to provide this themselves, which is why a third party is expected to do it.
Who Pays the Compliance Cost?
Regular reporting by a third party costs money, and the assumption appears to be that the landlord will pay. Landlords are already paying more tax than ever, and now face compliance that is not just greater, but more frequent. Note that these are the people providing housing for many households in the UK, given how many people do not own their own property. It is fair to ask whether this is the right strategy.
2.8 Million Landlords and Corporate Buyers
There are close to 2.8 million landlords, although the number is probably falling. They support the economy, create economic activity and pay tax. If they are squeezed to the point where they cannot afford to carry on, they will sell. Many of those properties end up with large corporate landlords such as BlackRock and Lloyds, which, in the view expressed in the video, receive special incentives to own residential property.
For anyone considering buying a residential buy-to-let in their own name, the costs of tax and compliance are becoming hard to justify, so it is worth thinking very carefully before doing so.
Limited Companies, Trusts and LLPs Affected
This is not only an issue for individuals. HMRC expects information from small limited companies that own property too, and properties held in a trust or a partnership such as an LLP are likely to be caught as well. The big question is who will pay for all of this, and it does not appear to have been thought through. If the burden keeps growing, the risk is that people simply stop letting property, which is not a good outcome for the UK economy or for tenants.
What Value Does This Give Anyone?
The key question is what value this regular reporting gives to anyone. HMRC believes it will help fund the tax gap, but that claim deserves to be challenged. A serious conversation is needed with the UK voter about what kind of country is wanted. Consider the end point of this trajectory: a country where housing is controlled by either the state or major corporates, rather than individuals, and where everyone has to go to them to live in a property.
Understanding the direction of travel matters, so that investment decisions are made with clarity. Links to the consultation and the discussion document will be shared so you can read the proposals and respond.
Prepare for Landlord Reporting with GoldHouse Accounting
With Making Tax Digital thresholds falling and HMRC pushing for regular third party reporting, landlords need to be organised and well advised. At GoldHouse Accounting, our property accountants and wealth management consultants help landlords understand their reporting obligations and decide whether holding property personally, in a company, in a trust or in a partnership is still the right structure. Get in touch to review your own portfolio.
This article reflects the views of Zee in the linked video and is based on consultation papers and proposals reported at the time of recording. The proposals may change and have not been finalised. This is not personalised tax or legal advice, so speak to a qualified adviser about your own circumstances.

