GoldHouse Accounting

Can HMRC Take Money From Your Bank Account?

HMRC Direct Recovery of Debts

HMRC already has powers to take money directly from bank accounts, and there is now a proposal to extend them. If you are one of the roughly 4.8 million people and businesses that HMRC believes owe it money, this could affect you directly. In this article, we explain how the powers work, why you might be worried about the proposed changes, and four practical steps to protect yourself and your business.

HMRC Direct Recovery of Debts Explained

The powers are known as Direct Recovery of Debts (DRD). They were introduced around 2015 and have since been amended, and the proposal now is to extend them further. In practice, HMRC can go into a personal or business bank account and take money it believes is owed, without the account holder’s permission. Since September 2025, HMRC claim 12 individuals/businesses have already had money taken from their accounts this way, equating to about £225,000 of debt claimed. This works out at almost £20,000 per individual/business.

This means that, as well as protecting against fraud, taxpayers now have to think about protecting themselves against mistakes in the recovery process itself.

4.8 Million Taxpayers and £40bn Owed

From past records, around 4.8 million people and businesses are potentially in scope, and HMRC believes it is owed roughly £40 billion.

It should go without saying that if you genuinely owe money to HMRC and you have that money, you should pay it- because that is how the system works. The concern is what happens when HMRC gets it wrong, which is why there have historically been so many safeguards around its powers.

The Proposed Limits

HMRC can take whatever it believes you owe, but the proposal sets minimum balances that must be left in the account:

Account Type Proposed Minimum Balance Left
Personal account £5,000
Business account £10,000

These limits are very low. It also isn’t clear whether there is a cap on how much can be taken. If you have committed costs coming through, such as payroll or supplier payments, you could go overdrawn or have payments bounce, is dangerous for you and your family financially.

HMRC Errors: A Real Example

The big problem is that HMRC makes mistakes, often because of its systems, and they take time to resolve. A recent example from one of our own clients: HMRC had allocated payroll payments incorrectly, and began sending letters on the basis of its own error. It took hours, and months of phone calls, to resolve. In the end, it turned out HMRC actually owed the business money, because the business had overpaid and interest had been allocated.

In that case it was a paper exercise. Under direct recovery powers, the money could instead be taken from the bank account before the error is found.

Risks for Staff, Suppliers and Cash Flow

If HMRC wrongly takes a substantial sum from a business account, the knock-on effects can be severe:

    • The business may be unable to pay its staff and suppliers.

    • The account could go overdrawn, and the bank could then close it.

    • Customers may not be paying, making a cash flow gap harder to cover.

    • The business could ultimately fail, and it’s unclear who would compensate the owner for HMRC’s mistake.

The HMRC Accountability Problem

Historically, accountability has been the sticking point. Anyone who deals with HMRC will tell you that, at best, you might get an apology, and often there’s no real accountability at all. Major bodies in the UK have raised this, including questions about what happens to business owners who have had money wrongly taken from their accounts for PAYE, VAT, corporation tax and other liabilities. The concern is that business owners currently have no real comeback.

Does HMRC Have Too Much Power?

The question is who gave HMRC these rights, and why. Is the government is blindly listening to HMRC, whom only sees the upside? If these thresholds are introduced and become the norm, it could be disastrous.

HMRC is likely testing the waters to see whether there is any fallout. If there isn’t, because the average person doesn’t know about this, the real question is what happens when the fallout eventually comes, and people who have money taken can’t even get it back. There are also cases where HMRC owes people money and hasn’t paid them. Perhaps, in fairness, those people should be able to take it directly from HMRC’s account…

How to Give Feedback to HMRC

The proposed changes to these thresholds are being discussed now. We strongly recommend you give your feedback when the consultation paper is open, because this is potentially disastrous for business owners and individuals. A link will be shared once the consultation is open.

4 Ways to Protect Your Business

    1. Give feedback to HMRC on the proposals while the consultation is open.
    2. Know your tax position. Stay on top of what you owe, so there are no surprises.
    3. If you are struggling, agree a plan with HMRC rather than leaving a debt unaddressed.

Final Thoughts

Can we really consider these measures financially responsible? They are being presented as a last resort, but once powers like this exist, they don’t normally end up being used that way. Hopefully this has been helpful.

Protect Your Business with GoldHouse Accounting

Knowing your tax position and acting early is the best defence against HMRC enforcement. At GoldHouse Accounting, our tax advisors and wealth management consultants help business owners understand where they stand, resolve HMRC issues, and plan ahead. Get in touch if you have a concern about your own position.

This article reflects Zee’s personal views and analysis of proposals reported at the time of recording. The limits and powers discussed are proposals and may change. This is not personalised tax, legal or insolvency advice, so speak to a qualified adviser before taking action on any HMRC debt or considering liquidation.

First Name *
Last Name *
Email *
Telephone *
What type of support are you looking for?
What budget have you allocated for specialist consultancy? *
Message
How did you hear about us? *

Ready to optimise your financial strategy?

Our team is here to help you secure sustained wealth and achieve long-term growth ac ross all your projects. Request you free 15-minute discovery call below.

How a discovery call works

requirements icon

1. COMPLETE FORM AND BOOK FREE DISOCVERY CALL

idea and goals icon

2. DISCUSS YOUR STRATEGIC GOALS

clarity icon

3. OUTLINE YOUR NEXT STEPS FOR CLARITY

First Name *
Last Name *
Email *
Telephone *
What type of support are you looking for?
What budget have you allocated for specialist consultancy? *
Message
How did you hear about us? *

GoldHouse Logo Mark
Privacy Policy Overview

At GoldHouse Accounting Ltd, we take your privacy seriously. This website uses cookies to provide essential site security, improve your browsing experience, and power our real-time support tools like our AI Chat Assistant (tawk.to).

We only use your data to provide our services and do not sell your personal information. You can change your mind and adjust your settings at any time. For a full breakdown of how we handle your personal data, your rights under the UK GDPR, and how to contact us, please read our full Privacy Policy.